Published weekly

November 1, 2007

Page 1   This week's print edition   Sun Dial briefs Advertising in The Alpine Sun Staff

Fire rekindles Blackwater site controversy in Potrero: Flames scorched valley walls  

By 
Miriam Raftery
The Alpine Sun

Top, the cloud of smoke rising in in the hills near Barrett Junction. Directly above, fire fighters work to put out embers still burning beneath the ground. Below, this is all that is left of one home and property in Potrero.

     POTRERO — “It won’t burn,” Blackwater West Vice President Brian Bonfiglio predicted in an interview published Friday, Oct. 26 in the Virginia Pilot. Asked about the Harris wildfire that had already ravaged the town of Potrero and scorched more than 80,000 acres, Bonfiglio expressed confidence that grazing cattle and the lack of trees or buildings would protect the 824-acre site where the company hopes to build a private military and law enforcement training camp.
     But by Friday afternoon, smoke was rising from Round Potrero Valley. A steep canyon wall towering above the single paved road in and out of the valley was blackened as fire crews worked to extinguish still-smoldering hot spots. Two canyon walls were charred from the rims to the valley floor. A large red stain from fire-retardant chemicals dropped by aircraft was evident just behind chicken coops at the valley’s north end.
     The valley floor was unburned and fire fighters battling the blaze camped there overnight, said Chuck Frank, safety officer with the Forest Service Department of Agriculture. “I heard an order for 350 meals,” he said, adding that backfires were set to limit the fire’s destructive path.
     In the fire’s critical first hours, however, little manpower was available to slow its spread. “I think the fires in other places, Los Angeles, got more priority,” Frank said.
     As flames reached the Blackwater site, DC10 planes dropped fire retardant chemicals and several hundred fire fighters were in the Potrero area. But the slow initial response heightened concerns among critics about future fires if the Blackwater facility is constructed.
     Blackwater seeks County approval to build 11 firing ranges, a vehicular training track, helicopter landing pad and other facilities, including bunkhouses to sleep 200 or more trainees. Critics have expressed concern that such operations pose a fire hazard to the community.

Blackwater says facility would make community safer
     Bonfiglio insists that Blackwater would not pose a fire risk and said he is pleased that the valley floor did not burn. “The concern was never a fire leaving the valley. It was a fire coming into the valley,” he said.
     He stated that Blackwater would not conduct bombing practices and that no flares or tracer ammunition would be used. Shooting areas would be surrounded by 24 foot-high berms and 150 feet of fuel modification to prevent rounds from entering brush or rocks on hillsides, he noted. “There will be a standby fire watch person when shooting is occurring and there will be fire equipment readily available,” Bonfiglio said.
     The Harris fire has not derailed Blackwater’s plans for Potrero, Bonfiglio confirmed, adding that the company’s six or seven proposed 35,000 water gallon storage tanks could be a benefit to the community. Blackwater has also offered to shelter-in-place residents in a building equipped with sprinklers and other fire protections slated to meet or exceed county and state standards.

Skeptics contend Blackwater would increase fire danger
     Opponents of Blackwater’s plans scoff at that notion that the proposed project would help protect the community.
     "You would never get me driving down that winding road to their private military base,” said resident Carl Meyer, leader of efforts to recall Potrero Planning Group members who voted for the Blackwater proposal. “It’s dangerous.”
     Ray Lutz, founder of www.stopblackwater.net, agreed. “The idea that the Round Potrero Valley could be an evacuation site or a staging area for fire crews went up in smoke as we witnessed the ferocity of a wildfire coupled with strong Santa Ana winds,” he stated in an e-mail to this reporter.
     “In the Harris Ranch fire, the valley was spared. However, if Blackwater builds their paramilitary boot camp in that boxed-in valley and is confronted by a similar fire, there is no doubt that the huge gasoline tank, the 18,000 square foot armory filled with tons of ammo, any structures, and the urban simulation areas would be a death trap.”
     The proposed facility would be situated immediately adjacent to Bureau of Land Management property, which Blackwater could not clear of densely-packed brush.

Potrero recall election will go forward
     More than 200 Potrero residents found themselves trapped for several days while fires raged. Some did not receive reverse 911 calls warning them to evacuate. Others chose to stay and fight to save their own homes, as many here have done in past fires, where help from outside came slowly or not at all.
     Thell Fowler, one of the planners facing recall for supporting Blackwater, saved several homes from burning. Jerry and Mary Johnson, two other planners facing recall, lost their house to the flames. Meyer doused hotspots to help his mother save her home.
     The fire in Potrero will not disrupt plans for the local planning group’s recall election, to be held Dec. 11 by mail-in ballot.
     “Any voters displaced by the fire do not lose their domicile for purposes of voting,” Registrar of Voters Deborah Seiler announced Tuesday. “We just need a mailing address so we can deliver ballots.”

Lolie Lopez, stirs up a pot of soup over a propane stove to feed some of her hungry and displaced neighbors.

     The majority of the 509 registered voters in the district pick up their mail at the Potrero post office, that resumed operations on Oct. 27, in advance of the Nov. 13 deadline for recall ballots to be in mailboxes.
     Voters who receive street delivery and whose homes are no longer habitable can apply for general delivery, a service offered by the U.S. Postal Service.
     At least 12 to 17 homes in Potrero have burned, estimated Jan Hedlun, the lone planner opposed to Blackwater.
     Left without power, Hedlun has been staying with Lolie Lopez, who operates the Potrero-Tecate Community Development Council, better known as “Community Soup.” Lopez lost her house to an electrical fire a year ago and watched in fear as burning embers ignited blazes around her newly rebuilt home.
     Stirring a pot of soup on a propane-powered camp stove set up in her kitchen, she described how she’s been feeding, “whoever comes in here. People stop in to find out how other people are doing. If they’re hungry or weary, we take care of them.”
     Her resilient spirit is characteristic of the independent frontier mindset of many Potrero citizens. “When there is this much devastation, your survival instincts kick in and you just do what has to be done,” Lopez said.

Blackwater and others bring in supplies
     Blackwater did help with relief efforts to reach Potrero on Wednesday, Oct. 24, bringing five loads of food and fuel to the area.

Potrero planner Jan Hedlun is still smiling, even though flames from the Harris Fire came within 30 feet of her house, she did not lose her home.

     “I’ve been trying to bring in enough to feed 300 people at a go, but I’m also going to bring in shovels and rakes to start help with cleanup,” said Bonfiglio. Assemblyman Joel Anderson, State Senator Denise Ducheney, former City Attorney Casey Gwinn, Rock Church in Point Loma and the Red Cross have also aided in relief efforts, with FEMA arriving over the past weekend.
     Volunteers at the emergency drop-off point set up at Chicano Park also helped, beginning Monday, making frequent trips to the Potrero area with what supplies were donated. Transported by volunteer drivers, including South Western College students, trucks were loaded to bring supplies to the small community.
     The Harris fire now proves how devastating a wildfire begun by a single spark in Potrero can be, not only for the town’s residents, but for people throughout San Diego County. The Harris fire scorched a path as far west as Otay Lake, forcing evacuations in Chula Vista.
     Fire burned to within 30 feet of Hedlun’s Potrero home, yet she considers herself fortunate.
“I spent three hours cleaning, but I was grinning,” she concluded, “because I still had something to clean.”


                                                E-mail the Editor


Page 1   This week's print edition   Sun Dial briefs
Advertising in The Alpine Sun Staff
If your business isn't showing up in the search engines, you need to call us!